On Friday, a federal appeals court in New Orleans told the House of Representatives that a spending bill it passed almost four years ago was passed the wrong way. The 5th circuit proxy voting ruling came down 9 to 8, and it hinges on a question nobody expected to matter this much: does a lawmaker sitting at home count as present?

The answer, at least from this court, is no. The judges concluded that the House broke the Constitution when it counted absent members toward a quorum on a $1.7 trillion funding package, as Reuters covered in its report on the appeals court ruling on the House’s 2022 spending bill. The immediate damage is narrow. The precedent is another story.
Here is what the judges actually decided, why seventeen of them split almost down the middle, what the ruling leaves alone, and where the fight probably goes next.
How a pandemic shortcut ended up in court
In May 2020, with the Capitol half empty and COVID-19 closing in, then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi pushed through House Resolution 965. The rule let a member who stayed home hand a vote to a colleague who showed up. It was sold as an emergency fix, and for a while it was.
Then it stuck around. The House kept extending it through the end of 2022, and Republicans, who disliked it from day one, went to court. Those cases went nowhere. Federal judges in Washington ruled that the Speech or Debate Clause shields lawmakers’ legislative work from that kind of lawsuit.
That closed the direct route. An indirect one stayed open: wait for a law passed by proxy, then challenge the law itself.
The chance came in December 2022. The House approved a $1.7 trillion funding package by 225 to 201, and 226 of those votes were cast by proxy. Inside the package sat the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, a bipartisan law that requires employers to make reasonable accommodations for pregnancy and childbirth. President Joe Biden signed it. Republicans took the House a few weeks later and scrapped proxy voting.
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton’s office then sued. A district judge, James Hendrix, blocked enforcement of the act against Texas in early 2024. A three-judge panel of the 5th Circuit reversed him 2 to 1 in August 2025. Then the full court wiped out that decision, took the case itself, and heard arguments in May 2026.
What the full 5th Circuit decided

Friday’s vote went the other way, 9 to 8. Judge Cory Wilson wrote for the majority, and his core point fits in a single sentence: a lawmaker who is not in the room is not present, whatever the House rulebook says.
The court read Article I, Section 5 of the Constitution as requiring a majority of members to be physically there to make a quorum. The House has wide freedom to write its own rules, the majority said, but a rule cannot override a requirement set by the Constitution itself.
Reuters described the outcome as powered by the court’s conservative majority. That tracks with the lineup: Wilson is a Trump appointee, and the lead dissent came from an Obama appointee.
For the House, the lesson is blunt. Emergency rules written for a crisis still have to survive a reading of the Constitution’s text, and this court read that text strictly even though the crisis was real.
The arithmetic behind the quorum problem
The numbers explain why this particular bill became the target.
- The final vote was 225 to 201.
- 226 members voted by proxy.
- The House has 435 seats, so a majority is well above 200.
Do the subtraction and roughly 200 lawmakers voted in person. That is short of a majority, which is exactly the gap Texas pointed to. Count the proxies as presence and the quorum is fine. Refuse to, and it is not.
Every one of those proxy votes was valid under the House’s own rules at the time. That is why the dispute is about the Constitution and not about procedure: the rulebook allowed it, and the question is whether the rulebook was allowed to.
Why eight judges disagreed
Judge James Graves Jr. wrote the main dissent. His argument is that the majority read a physical-presence requirement into a clause that never mentions one. The Constitution says a majority of each chamber makes a quorum to do business. It does not say where anyone has to be standing.
At the May hearing, Bloomberg Law reported, Graves pointed out that the framers knew about proxies and still wrote nothing to ban them. Wilson, meanwhile, noted that Congress never authorized proxy voting before 2020, not during the 1918 flu, not during the Civil War, not after September 11.
Same silence, opposite conclusions. That is the whole case in miniature.
There is also an older hurdle. The earlier panel leaned on an 1892 Supreme Court precedent that generally keeps courts from second-guessing how Congress passes its bills. Expect that doctrine to come back if the dispute climbs higher.
What the ruling does not do
The headline sounds seismic. The relief is not.
The court left the funding law standing. What it kept in place is an injunction barring the Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the pregnant-workers provision against Texas. Reuters called that relief narrow.
Graves seized on the mismatch. If the whole bill was passed unconstitutionally, he asked, why should the remedy cover only one small sliver of a multitrillion-dollar law? The majority, as reported, offered no explanation. It is the loosest thread in the opinion.
The decision also does not ban every form of remote participation in Congress. The case was about proxy presence, where one member’s vote is cast by another, and not about every possible way a lawmaker could join a session from afar.
Where the fight goes from here

Most observers expect an appeal to the Supreme Court. If the justices take it, they would decide whether presence by proxy can ever count toward a quorum, a question no high court has answered for the modern House.
The wider worry for supporters of the 2020 to 2022 rules is what comes after. Earlier reporting on the case noted that a win for Texas could invite challenges to other measures passed under the same system. Nobody has filed those yet, and the narrow remedy gives challengers less to work with. Still, the reasoning is out there now.
The politics are a little tangled, too. At earlier stages, the Justice Department under President Trump kept defending the pregnant-workers law, even as Republican-led Texas attacked it.
A ruling about quorum rules does not touch corporate balance sheets, so do not expect a market reaction. Readers who like to see how political and legal headlines play out in the market can keep an eye on the ANT stock price alongside the news.
Frequently asked questions
What did the 5th Circuit decide about proxy voting?
The full court held, 9 to 8, that the House violated the Quorum Clause when it counted absent members through proxy voting to pass the 2023 spending law. In the majority’s view, a quorum requires a majority of members to be physically present.
Is the whole $1.7 trillion spending bill now invalid?
No. The court left the law in place. The practical effect is an injunction stopping federal enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas. Reuters described the relief as narrow.
Does the ruling ban remote voting in Congress?
No. The case concerned proxy presence under the pandemic-era rule. It did not settle whether other kinds of remote participation would pass constitutional muster.
Could other laws passed with proxy votes be challenged?
It is possible. Coverage of the case has long flagged that risk. But the remedy here was limited to one provision and one state, so a broader attack would face the same open questions about scope.
Will the Supreme Court take the case?
Nothing is certain yet. An appeal is widely expected, but the justices choose which cases they hear. If they do, they would rule on whether proxy presence can ever count toward a House quorum.
Where this leaves Congress
Day to day, nothing changes on the House floor. Proxy voting ended in January 2023, and members now vote in person.
What changed is the precedent. A federal appeals court has said that “present” means present, and it said so about a law that millions of workers rely on.
Whether the Supreme Court agrees will decide if the COVID-era rule was a smart emergency workaround or a shortcut the Constitution never allowed. Until then, one Texas employment dispute carries a question that has been waiting since the Framers wrote Article I.
For more coverage like this, browse our politics news section.
